Andrew Kirkcaldy
This author account hasn't been claimed yet. To claim this account, please contact the outlet owner to request access.
Writing For
Latest Reviews
Still structurally lacking, but there's no denying Unlimited's appeal.
Devoid of ideas, hung up on laborious combat and obsessed with making even the exciting seem boring.
DmC Definitive Edition's customisation tools that allow the player to tweak gameplay to suit their own style is what makes this an excellent remaster for newcomers and veterans alike.
Far Cry 3 shines in its campaign, which is more layered and compelling than any game proffering a power trip through escapist ultraviolence has any right to be.
The strongest Lego title yet, and the best Marvel game ever made.
There's just enough style in F1 Race Stars to make it stand on its own.
A rewarding, idiosyncratic romp imbued with nonsense, humour, and pathos.
NieR: Automata has more creativity and self-awareness in its little finger than most games have for their entire run time. Don’t miss this because it’s sandwiched between other, bigger games.
Gears of War: judgment is a solid effort that, in some ways, changes the Gears formula for the better.
A few minor missteps don't manage to detract from what is one of the best games on the system.
There's almost certainly a great horror experience somewhere in all this Slender Man mythos but this isn't it. This is glorified Pac-Man in the dark.
CriticDB tracks 89 Andrew Kirkcaldy reviews, averaging 72/100. See the score distribution and their highest & lowest rated games below, or browse every Andrew Kirkcaldy score in the Reviews tab.
Andrew Kirkcaldy score distribution
- 90–10017
- 80–8929
- 70–7924
- 60–697
- 50–595
- Below 507
















