Andrew Kirkcaldy
This author account hasn't been claimed yet. To claim this account, please contact the outlet owner to request access.
Writing For
Latest Reviews
Fans of the original game and the superior Dynasty Warriors series may find something to enjoy here, but everyone else will be hard pressed to do the same.
With its mix-and-match gameplay, Sins is certainly a title out of the ordinary, but very much an acquired taste. However, once you've acquired the habit, it's a tough one to break.
The touchscreen control mechanic might not sit so well with old school fans, but for newcomers with a patient disposition, Toki Tori is a real treat from the App store.
With its spectacular design, dazzling polish and ever-compulsive gameplay, World of Warcraft seems destined to remain the everyman's pick of PvE-focussed MMO for the foreseeable future.
So basically, this new BattleZone succeeds - if by the skin of its teeth - in becoming an entertaining title.
While fundamentally similar to its predecessor, it comprehensively outdoes the original in every way. if you're broad-minded enough you'll be rewarded with the most entertaining game in years
The Bureau delivers the best squad shooter since Rainbow Six: Vegas, and is successful in spinning an intelligent and twisting narrative, filled with fan service.
Rayman Legends isn't perfect, but it's still a cracking game.
A brilliant, imaginative game for kids of all ages
A lacking campaign is made up for by a fresh multiplayer take on the franchise.
The strongest Lego title yet, and the best Marvel game ever made.
A rewarding, idiosyncratic romp imbued with nonsense, humour, and pathos.
CriticDB tracks 89 Andrew Kirkcaldy reviews, averaging 72/100. See the score distribution and their highest & lowest rated games below, or browse every Andrew Kirkcaldy score in the Reviews tab.
Andrew Kirkcaldy score distribution
- 90–10017
- 80–8929
- 70–7924
- 60–697
- 50–595
- Below 507

















